Make Some Pizza
Sauce recipe

New York–style cooked sauce

Slightly sweet, deeply seasoned, cooked down for 15–20 minutes. The garlicky pizzeria alternative for NY, Sicilian and Detroit pies.

TomatoCookedMakes 620 gNew YorkSicilianDetroitCast Iron Pan

Make the sauce

1 can makes about 620 g — enough for 5 Cast Iron Pan pans
1can

Drain the can over a bowl and keep the juice. Pinch off the stem ends, squeeze out the seeds, and crush the tomatoes by hand into a coarse pulp, adding juice back until it is loose enough to simmer. Heat the olive oil in a saucepan over medium. Add the garlic and cook 30 seconds until fragrant (do not brown). Add the tomatoes, salt, oregano, sugar, and optional red pepper. Simmer uncovered 15–20 min, stirring occasionally, until reduced by about a quarter. Let it cool before spreading it on the dough. Keeps refrigerated 5 days, frozen 3 months.

Whole peeled San Marzano tomatoes (28 oz can)Cento Certified San Marzano: tomatoes, puree, sea salt, basil. No citric acid.
1 can (28 oz)794 g
Garlic cloves, mincedAbout 2 cloves
2 cloves6 g
Extra-virgin olive oil
1 tbsp15 g
Fine sea salt
1 tsp5 g
Dried oregano
1 tsp2 g
SugarBalances acidity
½ tsp2 g
Red pepper flakesOptional
¼ tsp1 g
Pair with

Make a cast iron pan dough to match. The calculator opens with Cast Iron Pan pre-selected — pick skillet size and timing next.

Open dough calculator →